Now here's a cookie with an unusual name: Preacher Cookies. Peanut butter, oats, butter, and a little bit of chocolate, and that's just about all you need for a batch of Preacher Cookies. View top rated Preacher cookie recipes with ratings and reviews.

Ingredients of Preacher cookies

  1. Prepare of Sugar.
  2. It's of Cocoa.
  3. Prepare of Milk.
  4. You need of Margarine.
  5. Prepare of Vanilla.
  6. Prepare of Peanut Butter.
  7. It's of Quick Oats.

Preacher cookies step by step

  1. Mix sugar, cocoa, milk, margarine and vanilla in a pan..
  2. Bring to a boil on medium heat..
  3. Remove from burner and add peanut butter..
  4. Stir until peanut butter is melted..
  5. Add quick oats and stir..
  6. Drop by spoonfuls onto baking sheet covered with waxed paper..
  7. Let cool..

It should form medium sized cookies. By far the best cookie ever invented! These old-fashioned no-bake cookies earned their name because they can be made quickly and easily—like when the preacher shows up at the door. No reason to pre-heat the oven for these cookies! Everyone else's recipes are all slightly different from this one.

Get Latest Recipe : HOME